Peak Strain Meter
The Peak Strain Meter (PSM) from Fabrique Scientific,
Inc. is a device which monitors the output of a strain gage attached to the
barrel of firearm and displays the peak pressure in MicroStrain. The
technology used is similar to that used by the Oehler Model 43
Personal Ballistics Laboratory. The major difference is that the
Oehler unit requires the direct attachment of a computer while the gun is
fired. This would imply, for most us, that a portable computer would have
to accompany us to the range. The PSM is self contained, but only measures
the peak pressure, rather than the entire firing cycle. For most reloaders
that is sufficient. As a result of these differences, there is a
significant difference in cost as well. The current price of the PSM is
$150 and fully operational strain gage assemblies is $14 each. I purchased
the PSM and 3 strain gages for less than $200.
The PSM comes with a Windows software package to convert the meter
reading in Micro Strain to pounds/sq in (psi) and calculate the associated
pressure curve based on measured velocity and barrel length. The required
input values to the program are:
-
Barrel Outside Diameter (OD) - measured at the point of strain
gage attachment
-
Chamber or Barrel Inside Diameter (ID) - measured at the point
of strain gage attachment
-
Case Wall Thickness - measured at the point of strain gage
attachment
-
Barrel Length - from base of neck to the muzzle
-
Bullet Diameter
Bsaed on my preliminary use of the program it becomes obvious that
the accuracy of the measurements is critical to the accuracy of the
calculations.
Why Measure Pressure?
For reloaders determining safe pressures in handloads is full of
oportunities to make mistakes. Ask 20 reloaders how to determine whether a
load is safe and you'll get 20 differing answers with some significant overlaps.
The classic things you will hear are:
-
Sticky bolt lift
-
Cratered primers
-
Flattened primers
-
Black ring around primers
-
Blown primers
-
Loose primer pockets
-
Shiny spots on case heads
-
Excessive case head expansion
-
Excessive pressure ring expansion
For years these were the things I looked for to determine whether
my loads were "safe" or not. In following pressure related threads on
various boards and other reading, I have come to the conclusion that there are a
number of variables involved which make it difficult to be sure where you're at
pressure wise. Most of these indications apply reasonably well if you're
loading relatively high intensity cartridges in modern rifles. If, on the
other hand, you're loading for older weaker actions and associated cartridges
that ain't necessarily the case.
The SAAMI maximum pressures that you will find listed in various
reloading resources are many times set based on the strength of old guns which
may still be in use. For example, take the 45-70. My copy of the
Lyman Reloading Handbook - 47th Edition list loads in 3 separate categories,
1873 Springfield, 1886 Winchester or 1895 Marlin, and Ruger #1/#3. Loads
for the Springfield peak at 17000 CUP, the Winchester/Marlin loads peak at just
over 28000 CUP and the Ruger loads peak at 40000. All loads use large
rifle primers. These are the same primers you woud use in modern, high
intensity cartidges operating at maximums in excess of 50000 CUP safely. Do you
think its likely to ever see one flatten or crater in a 45/70? I doubt it.
Different brands and lots within brands of brass and primers vary
in how hard/soft they are. This results potentially masking real high
pressure loads or falsely indicating high pressures when they don't really exist
if the reloader isn't careful with components.
All in all, this has never given me a real warm, fuzzy
feeling. I have always stuck with load data from documented commercial
sources for this reason.
Getting Started
Assuming that you purchased the pre-soldered strain gage
assemblies, or assmebled them yourself, from here on when use the term "gage", I
am referring to the whole assembly not just the physical strain gage
itself. (For details on installing the gage and setting up the meter)
I took the measurements listed above as program inputs while I had the action
out of the stock to attach the gage to the bottom of the chamber for
esthetics.
|